Should I Paint My Siding or Replace It? Good Question!

calander Mar 22 , 2023 user-icon Nash Painting

If you're a homeowner aiming to spruce up your home's exterior, you're probably looking long and hard at your siding. Maybe you're wondering: "Should I paint my siding or replace it?" It's a valid question! In this blog post, we'll evaluate the pros and cons of each approach.

Table of Contents:

  • Repainting Your Siding

  • Replacing Old Sidings

  • Painting vs Replacing

  • Conclusion

Repainting Your Siding

Repainting your siding is a cost-effective way to restore the natural beauty of wood and vinyl siding. Urethane acrylic paints and specialized latex paints are recommended for optimal results, as they provide long-lasting protection against harsh weather conditions.

Wooden siding should be washed with a pressure washer prior to painting in order to remove dirt and debris that can cause paint failure. After washing, use an oil-based primer before applying two coats of urethane acrylic paint. This type of paint is designed specifically for wooden surfaces because it offers superior adhesion properties compared to traditional latex paints which may chip or flake off over time due to moisture absorption from rain or snowfall. Additionally, lighter colors will reflect more sunlight which helps keep your home cooler during summer months while still providing adequate UV protection from fading caused by direct sunlight exposure over time.

painting vs replacing siding

Painting vs Replacing

When deciding between painting and replacing old sidings, it's important to consider both the maintenance requirements and upfront costs. Painting is usually a more cost-effective option than replacement in the short term, but over time climate factors such as hot humid temperatures can cause paint to peel or crack which could lead to further damage.

If you’re unsure of whether or not your house needs new siding, there are several signs that indicate when it’s time for a replacement. These include:

  • Rotting boards

  • Cracks and holes

  • Gaps

  • Bubbles

  • Moisture damage

  • Warping

  • Fading or chalking

Key Takeaway: When it comes to siding, you have the option of painting or replacing. Painting is usually cheaper in the short-term but could cost more if paint starts to peel due to weathering over time. Alternatively, replacement may be a better choice for an aesthetic upgrade and increased property value.


When deciding whether to paint or replace your siding, cost and longevity should be taken into account before making a final decision. Weigh the cost of painting versus replacing and consider how long each option will last before making a choice. Ultimately, only you know what is best for your home so make sure to do thorough research, and get the advice of a local home improvement professional too.

If you're looking for a high-end painting solution to improve the appearance of your siding, Nash Painting is here to help. We offer professional services that will make sure your home looks its best and last for years to come.